Precinct Parking

NYPD takes Broadway

Share
Precinct Parking
Vehicles parked around the 34th Precinct station house. Visual: The Lighthouse Washington Heights. Photos: TLWH + reader-submitted images

Walk north on Broadway from 181st Street, and you’ll soon hit a zone where certain traffic rules seem magically suspended. On the blocks around the 34th Police Precinct’s headquarters, NYPD officers park on sidewalks. They park in crosswalks. They park in lanes on Broadway.

The city calls areas like this “self-enforcement zones,” which one report describes as an area around a police facility where traffic cops generally don’t issue tickets, and the commanding officer gets to set the terms. In practice, this means officers can drive to work and park their cars perpendicular to the curb, half on the sidewalk, half in the street, a habit called “combat parking.” (Maybe piggy-backing on the sense of lawlessness, some drivers unconnected to the 34th Precinct seem to be combat parking in the area, too.)

For some people, this is just a fact of life — maybe even a fair price to pay to support police officers’ work. For others, it’s a source of rage.  

“The cops park wherever the fuck they want, ’cause they got license to do that,” one man told me, while his van was stuck behind a school bus, which was stuck beside a row of creatively parked cars, which were blocking a sizeable chunk of 183rd Street. “They abuse their fucking authority,” the man said. “It’s common sense.”

“We Know That It’s a Problem”

The area on Broadway is particularly snarled. Residents told me that the situation has been getting worse, at least in part because construction has closed a big chunk of the parking lot behind the station house. 

On Monday morning, around 8:30 a.m., combat- and double-parked vehicles had cut Broadway down to a little more than one lane. Large vehicles took turns driving through, some going uptown, some going down. I timed an M100 bus and found that it took almost four minutes to travel from 184th Street to 182nd. 

Then, a Bx7 bus and a concrete truck tried to pass each other. They got stuck. Broadway stopped moving. Honking kicked up. The bus driver got out to survey the situation and gestured, incredulous, at a double-parked patrol car that could have easily been a foot closer to the curb. 

A couple of minutes passed. Someone said that the cops couldn’t find their keys.

I hopped on the bus and interviewed a passenger, a young-ish man in a blue baseball cap who declined to give his name. “It is peak rush hour, people have to get to work, and they are double-parking,” he said. He yelled out the bus door, “This is unprofessional!” 

Stuck! Credit: Michael Schulson / TLWH

NYPD officers work long hours, sometimes in dangerous conditions. They’re not allowed to live in the precincts where they work. Many of them commute from the suburbs, sometimes at weird hours. In the past, the argument from the NYPD has been that officers need parking, plus the department has a lot of vehicles. Unless the city builds more designated lots for each station house, these vehicles are going to take up some space. “We listen to our communities, we know that it’s a problem,” one senior NYPD official told the City Council in 2023, according to amNY. “We’re trying our best,” he added. 

Back in 2022, then-graduate student Marcel Moran spent a month visiting police precincts across the city. In a subsequent academic paper, he reported finding “obstructive parking” at 70 of 77 station houses.

“This is a chronic illegal use of the sidewalk,” Moran told me this week. (He’s now an assistant professor at San Jose State University, studying urban transportation.) In the paper, he cites references to the practice stretching back to the mid-1990s.

This kind of parking can make it hard for people with wheelchairs and strollers to use the sidewalks. It also sends a bad message, he told me: “It’s a constant reminder of impunity by our police force. And that adds up and changes the relationship of the public to the police.” 

“There are ways we can resolve this,” Moran added. “We can build adequate parking facilities for the staff of police stations.” Other people I spoke with suggested that the police should just deal with commuting hassles like everyone else. “The vast, vast, vast majority of New Yorkers do not work in the very precincts they call home, and yet they still manage to get there without double parking or illegally parking on the sidewalk,” said Alexa Sledge, the communications director for the advocacy group Transportation Alternatives. 

The sidewalk narrows. Credit: Michael Schulson / TLWH

In March 2024, federal prosecutors accused the NYPD of violating the Americans with Disabilities Act by blocking sidewalks and crosswalks. The city’s Department of Investigation, a watchdog agency, asked the NYPD to stop allowing self-enforcement zones, describing wayward parking by city employees as “a form of corruption.” Multiple traffic cops told investigators that they would be disciplined if they booked a vehicle in these zones.  

According to Streetsblog, the NYPD declined to follow the recommendation.

Second-Place in NYC

When I reached out to other city agencies, they didn’t seem eager to discuss the NYPD’s parking practices. Would the Department of Investigation like to comment on the NYPD’s decision to ignore them? No. Could the Department of Transportation answer my basic questions about whether it’s legal for officers to park on sidewalks and in crosswalks? “We would refer you to the NYPD here.”

I contacted the NYPD for comment on this story, but representatives of the 34th Precinct did not respond to emails, phone calls, or a handwritten message left at the station house. The NYPD’s public-information office also did not respond to repeated requests for comment. 

Noemi Diaz, a member of Community Board 12, asked Virginia Peralta, a community-affairs officer at the precinct, about the traffic situation around 183rd and Broadway at a meeting in February. “A lot of parents have been complaining in regards to there not being space on the sidewalk to cross,” Diaz said. Peralta explained that “unfortunately the cops have had to double park all up 183rd between Broadway and Wadsworth” because bus-mounted cameras were catching them when they parked on Broadway. 

“Officers, sometimes, if they’re late to work, they’ll just double-park the car really quick and then move it,” Peralta added. 

This is a busy intersection. There are four schools within two blocks, and the Bx7 and M100 buses travel that stretch of Broadway. Public records show that passers-by sometimes call 311 to complain about parking there. As of 2024, according to the Department of Investigation report, those kinds of 311 complaints were routed to the NYPD, where uniformed officers would often dismiss them without a response. 

“It’s legal only because the NYPD says it’s legal,” said Gersh Kuntzman, the editor in chief of Streetsblog. He described the situation to me as “a fucking scandal.” In 2021, when Streetsblog hosted a March Madness-style bracket to identify the precinct with the worst offenses, the 34th was the runner-up.

“We Will Use Enforcement”

As it happens, congestion in that part of the neighborhood has recently been a significant point of concern for the 34th Precinct’s top brass. Earlier this year, as Zeta Charter Schools sought permission to build a campus at the corner of 181st Street and Broadway, the NYPD vigorously opposed the proposal. One objection was that the school’s dropoff and pickup would worsen traffic. 

"Now if we look at the traffic on Broadway, that's going to be even more of a disaster,” Inspector John Portalatin, the commanding officer of the precinct, told one Community Board 12 committee. “We have people trying to get to work.” The NYPD would try to send out their traffic team to control the situation around the school, he said: “We will use enforcement if people are double parked.”

💡
Want more local journalism about the Heights? Sign up for The Lighthouse's free weekly newsletter.

Have a story tip? Email mhschulson@gmail.com, or message me on Signal (Schulson.17) or WhatsApp (646-279-6952).

© 2026 TLWH LLC | The Lighthouse Washington Heights is published by TLWH LLC