P.S. 187 FAQ
Digging into the details of a major construction project.
Since March, I've been reporting on plans to build an addition onto P.S. 187, the large elementary and middle school on Cabrini Boulevard.
This is a major construction project that would affect one of the largest public schools in Upper Manhattan, and I'm getting lots of questions about it from readers. So I've pulled together a quick FAQ, with the goal of providing a clear and unbiased account of what's going on.
For more reporting on P.S. 187 and other District 6 schools, subscribe to The Lighthouse's weekly newsletter. And if you appreciate this kind of in-depth local journalism, please consider joining The Lighthouse as a paid member.
What's going on?
P.S. 187 does not have the space it needs to comply with a new class-size law passed by the state legislature in 2022. City officials plan to spend $113 million on a five-story addition to the school.
What will it look like?
The School Construction Authority hasn't shared any designs with the public. They say it will include nine general-education classrooms, four special-education classrooms, seven early-childhood classrooms, a science lab, music and art rooms, and a new cafeteria. The addition will be built on a portion of the P.S. 187 schoolyard.
Why is it so big?
It's not clear. By my calculations, last year the school could have met the class-size requirements with just four new classrooms for its K-5 students. (The picture for the middle school is fuzzier.)
One theory is that city officials plan to increase the total enrollment of P.S. 187 ā effectively consolidating more of the district's students in a popular, high-performing school. City officials have repeatedly said that's not the plan, and that overall enrollment will not increase.
I asked Onika Richards, an NYC Public Schools spokesperson, if she could help explain the math. Richards referred my question to the School Construction Authority. An SCA spokesperson then referred me ... back to NYC Public Schools. I'm now waiting on a response.
What's the timeline?
The SCA plans to present designs to the community early next year. Construction is scheduled to begin at some point in 2027, and the SCA hopes to welcome students in September 2030.
Is it an addition or an annex?
An addition. An annex is freestanding; this structure will be connected to the existing school building.
What are the potential benefits?
- The addition will allow P.S. 187 to shrink class sizes without having to turn away students.
- It will bring brand new facilities, including a science lab, to the school.
- The addition represents a major investment of city dollars in the neighborhood.
What are the potential downsides?
- Years of construction may be disruptive for students, teachers, and neighbors.
- The project will take away a large portion of the schoolyard, a beloved community gathering space.
- The city will be investing more than $100 million in a big building at a time when enrollment in District 6 schools is plunging.
What happens if it doesn't get built?
P.S. 187 might have to shrink its enrollment by turning away some students who are applying to the school but don't live in the zone. That could direct more students to other, under-enrolled schools in the district. It's also likely to make P.S. 187's student body relatively wealthier and whiter, reflecting the demographics of people who are zoned for the school. Fewer students at the school might also mean cuts to the school's budget.
Is this legal?
A state law restricts repurposing school playgrounds for other uses ā but only if there's no plan to provide adequate "space to accommodate the physical and recreational needs of the pupils."
At a public meeting in early November, Nicole Holloway, a School Construction Authority official, said that around 15,000 square feet of schoolyard will remain when construction is done.
Who made the decision to build it?
I don't know. City officials did consult with school leaders and parents about the overcrowding issue, but I'm yet to get a clear answer about who made the final call or to see documents detailing the decision-making process. Iām working on it.
How can people get involved?
If you hate this idea, there's a petition for you to sign.
If you love this idea, I'm not aware of any organized effort to back the plan. If that changes or I'm missing something, please send me a message and I'll update this.
If you want to register your opinion, Community Education Council 6 meetings are a good place to start.
Standard disclosure for all education stories: I have children enrolled in District 6 schools.