The Skeleton on Broadway

The strange story of 4452 Broadway.

Share
The Skeleton on Broadway
4452 Broadway. Credit: Michael Schulson / TLWH

Not all is well on the stretch of Broadway between Fairview Avenue and 187th Street. On one corner is the frame of a half-finished apartment building, its construction stalled for years. It looms over the entrance to the 1 train tunnel — a decaying, poorly lit passageway filled with pools of standing water. Walk just a few feet down Broadway, and you arrive at Gorman Park, which has been mostly shuttered since a retaining wall collapsed in March 2017. 

I wrote about Gorman Park this spring, and — in response to many reader requests — I’ll get to the tunnel soon. But first: What’s the deal with that building? 

The Vision

Around 2012, a real-estate development firm called HAP Investments began buying property in upper Manhattan. “Land prices were attractive in these emerging neighborhoods,” HAP co-founder Eran Polack later told Leaders Magazine. “There was long-term potential.” 

In 2013 a company linked to HAP, called 4452 Broadway Mazal LLC, purchased property at the corner of Broadway and Fairview for $7.3 million, according to city records. (“Mazal” is a Hebrew word referring to luck or fortune, as in Mazal tov!) One early architectural rendering shows plans to build a seven-story, 129-unit building there. 

In 2015 developers decided to expand the scope, aiming for a 16-story building. But they ended up settling for a more modest design. A rendering shows a seven-story building that follows the curve of Fairview, with airy top-floor apartments and retail space on the ground floor. 

The site in 2017, pre-demolition. Source: Google Street View

Demolition began in May 2019. By the summer of 2021, a seven-story structure was underway. But work stopped. 

According to a bankruptcy court filing, in January 2022 loans for the project matured, and 4452 Broadway Mazal LLC did not repay them in time. The LLC filed a bankruptcy petition the next year. It had obtained around $50 million in loans from a Madison Avenue lender, according to one court document. 

Bad Mazels

What went wrong? When I emailed Polack to ask why the work had stalled, he responded with one word: “Covid.” He didn’t elaborate, and he didn’t respond to my subsequent messages.

According to reporting in the Israeli news site Ynet, Polack and two HAP colleagues sent a letter to investors in 2025 explaining that pandemic-related disruptions, along with inflation and interest-rate hikes that increased costs, had ultimately tanked the project. (Nir Amsel, one of Polack’s HAP co-founders, did not reply to my LinkedIn messages and emails. A phone number listed for HAP Investments is no longer in service; a website associated with the firm seems to have gone offline.) 

Ynet reported that hundreds of Israeli investors collectively faced the loss of tens of millions of dollars on the Broadway project. 

In 2024, the site went to the project’s lender, Madison Realty Capital. Last year, Madison sold it for $15.3 million to Three Pillars, a real-estate development firm headquartered in New Jersey. 

This isn’t the only empty lot in the neighborhood with ties to HAP Investments. In 2012, LLCs connected to the firm bought a series of properties along 187th Street between Broadway and Wadsworth, aiming to build a 47-unit structure with a distinctive design. In 2015, HAP posted images on its Instagram page of the site pre- and post-demolition.  

The empty lot on 187th street. Credit: Michael Schulson / TLWH

Today, it’s the big empty lot across the street from P.S. 48 and the Church of St. Elizabeth, and it’s filled with trash and weeds. 

There appears to be some complicated litigation associated with the site. City property records list an LLC with a connection to HAP owning the lot. Public data from the NYC Department of Finance shows hundreds of thousands of dollars in unpaid taxes on the site. 

“A Hot Mess”

These stalled projects have company. Despite a serious housing shortage in NYC, the neighborhood is studded with empty lots and long-shuttered buildings — at Wadsworth and 184th Street, along Overlook Terrace, on 179th Street.

I asked Hayley Raetz, the policy director of the NYU Furman Center, which studies housing and urban policy, why lots sit empty uptown despite the housing shortage. “Right now the cost environment for development is pretty tough,” she told me. Interest rates are high; so are construction costs. She told me that in a neighborhood like Washington Heights, achievable rents don’t necessarily promise enough revenue to cover those costs. “It's going to be easier for a property to pencil” — i.e., make financial sense — “in a neighborhood with higher market-rate rents, like Lower Manhattan,” Raetz said.

As for the project at 4452 Broadway: What’s going to happen to this empty shell of a building? Three Pillars, the current owner, presumably has an incentive to develop it; public records show that the annual tax bill is around $200,000. 

A representative of Three Pillars did not return my emails and calls. City records suggest that the firm is yet to obtain a loan to start construction; they may still be working to raise capital. 

One real-estate developer told me it’s rare for a project to stall for so long, once construction has already begun. “It’s a hot mess,” the developer said. “I’ve never seen anything like this — like, quite this bad.” 

💡
Want more local journalism about the Heights? Sign up for The Lighthouse's free weekly newsletter.

Have a story tip? Email mhschulson@gmail.com, or message me on Signal (Schulson.17) or WhatsApp (646-279-6952).

© 2026 TLWH LLC | The Lighthouse Washington Heights is published by TLWH LLC